Living with More Than One Dog

Living with more than one dog can be a rewarding experience. Knowing how to prevent problems and teaching dogs how to share resources so they do not bully each other, or pester you, is pivotal to having a harmonious multi-dog home.

Living with more than one dog can be a rewarding experience. Dogs love the company of other dogs. Knowing how to prevent problems and teaching dogs how to share resources so they do not bully each other, or pester you, is pivotal to having a harmonious multi-dog home.

If you regularly let your dogs work it out among themselves, you give them a clear signal that you do not want to be involved when there is social conflict. If there is then an emergency, and you need to get your dogs’ attention, they will be less likely to look to you for guidance.

Dogs will frequently compete over resources. Resources include your attention, eye contact, affection, and praise; locations in the house and in the car; toys, balls, bones, food, and beds. A little preparedness on your part can go a long way toward preventing conflict. Your dogs should wait their turns for affection and food, respond to their names, and know how to sit, stay, look at you, and leave or drop objects.

    • Teach your dogs that all toys, affection, games, play, and petting come from you only when they are nice to each other. If they misbehave or bully each other for resources and your attention, give them a time-out or remove what triggered the behavior. Make sure the situation is managed so the problem does not reoccur.


    • Provide plenty of resources for your dogs so that there is little competition between them. If you have only one food bowl, dog toy, or dog bed, your dogs will be forced to take turns or fight over them.


    • Say your dogs’ names routinely so each dog can figure out who is being focused on. If other dogs get involved when you are focusing on an individual, turn your back on the intruders or look away from them.


    • Do not give your dogs attention for being nudgy, barking at you, jumping on you, or bullying each other. Don’t pet your dogs when they barricade you or push themselves on you. Teach your dogs impulse control, and reward polite manners.


    • All dogs should wait for treats and meals or have places to go when they eat so that they do not intrude on each other.

    • Dogs should wait or be taught to sit before they go outside. Please do not ask an older dog to sit; older dogs frequently have hip and knee problems, and sitting can be painful for them. Ask older dogs to wait or stay instead. The goal is not for your dogs to sit, but for them to not barge through doors when you open them. If you have a young dog who regularly hesitates when you ask him to sit, take him to a veterinarian.


    • When you pet one dog and another dog intrudes so that he becomes the center of attention, if you reward him you are rewarding that behavior. The dogs then compete for your attention, and one dog will inevitably be driven away. This does not set a good precedent for you as a leader.


    • If you are petting a dog and another dog barges in and pushes that dog away, ignore the dog who intruded by looking away or turning your back to him. Continue petting the other dog. If he begins to nudge or growl at the dog who is receiving attention from you, stand up and look away from both dogs. When the dog who growled or nudged his way in sees that his behavior did not work for him and loses interest, go back and pet the dog you had been giving attention to.


    • If dogs growl at each other over an object or a bone, remove it. If a dog has a toy or other object and another dog intimidates him by staring at him, interrupt the stare and direct that dog to another behavior. If one dog takes a toy or an object from another dog or makes that dog drop the object or leave the area, remove the item from the dog who took it and give it back to the dog who originally had it. You may have to do this multiple times, but your dogs will get a message from you: bullying behavior doesn’t work. You will notice a remarkable change in your dogs’ behaviors. The dog who may be regularly harassed or bullied will thank you, and there should be less conflict between the dogs in the future.

[dcs_head top=”0″ color=”#666666″] [/dcs_head]
Alana Stevenson provides Skype and phone consults and can be reached through her website . You can purchase a copy of a her book Training Your Dog the Humane Way on Amazon.

7 thoughts on “Living with More Than One Dog

  1. I have a two dogs and did take the toy away from the dog that bullied the other dog and gave it bck to him. The dog attacked the other dog. I had to pull the dog off. It was very visious. She is a rescue. What was not expecting the attack and it really scared me. What do you suggest? other

    1. Hi. I stumbled upon this since this article was from last year. If you try some of the approaches to maintain order or establish a bit of equality or fairness between the dogs and a fight ensues or aggression escalates, this is because the problem was far more serious than you initially realized and has been on-going. The victim dog, your boy, has most likely been compensating and deferring to avoid conflict, knowing that your female would escalate and attack if he stood up for himself. The triggers have most likely been overlooked and the negative behaviors have been rewarded or unacknowledged for a very long time. Your victim dog has maintained order through complete deference and most likely aggressive behaviors by the female have been rewarded. Since you changed things around, your female took it out on your male to ensure things returned back to ‘normal.’ She probably controls all the dynamics and all the attention you provide by controlling him. You can contact me through my website I do provide phone and Skype/video consultations. Understanding the precursors to aggression i.e., a dog’s body language and in what situations certain body-language is being shown will be very important. Or, you can find a humane trainer/behaviorist in your area to help you.

  2. I just could not leave your site prior to suggesting that I actually enjoyed the standard information an individual provide for your visitors? Is gonna be back frequently in order to check out new posts

  3. Two weeks ago, we rescued a dog from our local vet’s office from being euthanized for aggression towards a toddler and his former owner. The problem we’re having at home is not actually aggression from the smaller new dog, but from our existing dog…who out weighs him by about 55 lbs. everything was great for the first two weeks, then over the past 2 days, she has gone after him 3 times…once behind my husbands back, once behind my back and once in the back yard, when neither one of us were there. I just heard it in the house. So far I can’t seem to determine the trigger or stop the madness. The new dog is now terrified of our coonhound, which is a trigger itself. The bigger dog has not hurt the smaller one as of this time…but I can’t count on that going forward. I don’t know how to blend this pack. Please help.

    1. …a bit more to the story: we’ve tried to share our affections equally amount the dogs, but the new one can be a bit pushy. I try not to reward that behavior. Our current dog asks to get on the couch with us. The new dog has not learned to ask, therefore rarely is allowed on the couch with the coonhound, my husband and me. Am I creating a problem by empowering the coonhound? Now I’m afraid to invite the little dog up since he always wants to sit in my lap. If I make him sit at the other end of the couch, am I not favoring my dog regardless and still causing a problem. The coonhound’s place is always right beside me on the couch and every where else. I’m afraid if I invite him up now, it will cause a fight, based on the way my coonhound watches the little dog when I call him over.
      I have always separated their feeding areas, since the existing dog will resource guard with other dogs around. In addition, the new dog still need to learn the rules of the house, which our coonhound learned long ago. The new dog regularly gets trained in the right behaviors, as my current pup watches. I don’t know if she thinks she can correct him too.

      1. Hi. I stumbled upon this since this article was from last year. It does sound like you may be contributing to the behavior, however, it seems this has been on-going, even though you’ve only had the pup a few weeks now. Please contact me through my website I do provide phone and Skype/video consultations. There are many variables that can be contributing to the behaviors you have concerns about. Often aggression becomes out of control or more difficult to manage when precursors to the aggression are overlooked. Often the dogs will tell you this through their body-language i.e., staring or fixating, body-blocking, looking anxious or uncomfortable, lip-licking, avoiding eye-contact. Once you find the triggers, you can manage and resolve the negative association between the dogs or the negative association your coonhound has for your new little one.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.