Diet and Your Pet’s Food

Life With Dogs is reader-supported. We may earn a small commission through products purchased using links on this page.

Quite some time ago, I called a fairly large pet food manufacturer (of ‘higher quality’ pet food) and gave them my ‘what for.’ I had reluctantly bought a bag hoping that my feline friends would eat it without looking away as if— you’ve got to be kidding, you want me to eat what? When I opened the bag of what was supposedly a myriad of dried sea creatures and avian parts, I found animal hairs. Tired of throwing numerous bags and cans away over the years, and fed up, I made the phone call. And I was surprised when I received a call back the next morning. This particular brand used to be a dog and cat food I recommended to clients a decade ago. But within a year or so, they were bought out and the quality went from bad to worse.

Being an animal behaviorist for dogs and cats, I have seen “higher-quality” pet foods I had recommended fizzle in quality while increasing in price (I’ve noted this trend too doing my own personal grocery shopping). I usually get asked pet foods and products I recommend. At this point, none seem to come to mind. I myself have gone to feeding animals more ‘human-grade’ food or what is often called “people” food. Pet food was manufactured so companies could make money off of the slop and wastes from slaughterhouses.

Virtually all of the ‘higher quality’ or better pet foods have been bought out. Many by multinationals such as Colgate-Palmolive and Proctor & Gamble. Puppies universally never want to eat Iams, Eukanuba, and Science Diet. Many foods promoted as ‘allergy-free’ are loaded with cornmeal and corn gluten (allergens for many animals). Cornmeal is a notorious culprit in many skin ailments—itching, mysterious infections, and sores that are traditionally treated with steroids. Many white dogs are especially sensitive to skin problems. Steroids, of course, rarely relieve the problems long term, and in the case of mysterious skin issues, itchiness, and licking between the toes, often not at all. And although high-protein, grain free dog foods are popular, they are not necessarily great alternatives. Many dogs who are fed ‘grain free’ dry dog foods eat grass like it’s going out of style.  Grass is actually very nutritious. These dogs who are craving it are not getting enough roughage or fiber in the food from quality cellulose (found in plants).

And now, of course, the vast majority of products or ingredients are made in and shipped from China or Asia. Made in China, lack of labeling, grotesque pesticides, and rampant genetic engineering of plants and animals is now a crisis with food we consume. It becomes even more appalling when we consider what is in animal feed and in ‘pet’ products.

The ridiculous numbers of pet deaths and on-going pet food recalls that never seem to end speaks for itself. Pet food is the bottom of the barrel of unmentionables and disgusting, cheap fillers. Instead of simply suggesting that clients avoid packaged pet food and treats that contain artificial colors and flavors, as well as animal “digest”, “rendered” animal products, by-products, corn meal and corn gluten, I recommend they skip most packaged and processed pet food altogether. This is much easier to do for dogs than for cats who have very specific nutritional requirements.

The terrible ingredients that go into pet food and animal feed has been an issue for decades. When I was about nine or ten years old, I was given the book Natural Health for Dogs & Cats by Dr. Pitcairn (I read every page). I don’t think we would live a healthy life on fortified corn flakes mixed with some waste products and moldy fillers. So why do we expect other animals can?

What do I suggest now?

There are many homemade recipes you can prepare for your dog and kitty, including recipes for those dogs and cats who suffer from unknown allergies. Not Fit for A Dog: The Truth about Manufactured Dog and Cat Food, by Dr. Michael Fox is a good book to learn about what goes into pet food (Dr. Fox, an animal advocate and veterinarian, gave a very nice testimonial for my book, Training Your Dog the Humane Way). Dr. Pitcairn’s book also has a number of recipes.

My clients have trained with peaches, apples, bananas, carrots, cashews, sweet potatoes, and carob and molasses treats. I have a little arsenal of kitty treat recommendations for my kitty clients. One of my clients baked carob and molasses “fudge” brownies and pumpkin bread for her deaf Great Dane’s training sessions. Some of my clients have bought dehydrators to make their own dehydrated dog snacks. It’s not only cheaper that way, but they don’t have to worry about a recall.

Many of my clients have been more than happy to steer away from heavily processed pet foods and switch to more holistic, healthy food for their dogs and cats. Often the changes are immediate, such as healthier and glossier coats, less itchiness, and more relaxed temperaments.


Alana Stevenson can be reached through her website

6 thoughts on “Diet and Your Pet’s Food”

  1. when he was a puppy, my dog would get almost exactly halfway through a bag and then refuse to eat it. when i switched to a “higher quality” dog kibble, it ran me $45 for a bag that was supposed to last 21 days. instead, he ran through it in ten – feeding him the “recommended guidelines” left him a walking bag of bones. the cats would tear through a $6 bag of kibble in 4 days.

    switched to raw food – no more problem.

    yes, he eats grass; so much so that one of my running jokes is “don’t mind me – just walking my goat” and ppl say they can tell when we’ve been by bec of the neatly trimmed ditch. doesn’t bother me – i live in the country so the grass is about as wholesome as you can get without growing it hydroponically in your own basement.

  2. I applaud people who can afford to cook or feed raw to their dogs. I have three and my income is the only income. I would love to do this, but I can’t afford to. I wish someone would come up with an alternative that isn’t garbage. It used to be that you could count on kibble, but it appears that no one makes a quality food any more.

  3. Uh…while I encourage people to take an interest in what they’re feeding their pets (and themselves), I’m not sure how a self-professed “animal behaviorist” could be considered any sort of expert in animal nutrition, an entirely separate field of study.

  4. It is frustrating to find a great new pet food, get everyone switched to it and then over the next few years the quality goes down and the one with the most severe allergies begins to itch AGAIN! The hunt begins again and the process is repeated every year or two. I don’t balk much at price because the cost of the food is a lot cheaper than the vet bills from feeding them crappy food. And, that doesn’t even take into account that I want my pets happy and healthy and not suffering from what I feed them! Why can’t even one company make high quality hypoallergenic food and keep making it??!!??

  5. What are we supposed to feed our. Pets?
    I do not know. I have quit Science diet/Hills.
    Quit eukanuba. Quit pro plan.
    I don’t know what to do .


Leave a Comment