Judge has Harsh Words for Man who Hurled Dog to the Floor

Life With Dogs is reader-supported. We may earn a small commission through products purchased using links on this page.

A Wheatfield, NY man was sentenced to five years’ probation on Thursday for fracturing a dog’s pelvis.  Jason E. Evrard, 27, smashed his grandmother’s dog to the floor when it killed one of his kittens.

Jan Evrard was forced to surrender her eight-year-old Lhasa Apso, named Abby, to the Niagara County SPCA because she could not afford the X-rays and medical treatment required after her grandson’s violent reaction.

Evrard pleaded guilty to the felony count of aggravated cruelty to animals.  State Supreme Court Justice Richard Kloch Sr. changed his initial sentence of one year in jail to five years’ probation.  Evrard has already served just under six months.  But the judge had plenty to say to the offender.

“You served 176 days and you deserved every one of them, and you deserve more,” Kloch said.  “People think probation is a slap on the wrist.  It’s worse than if I sentenced you to straight time.”

Evrard agreed.  If he doesn’t stay out of trouble for the next five years, he will be sent to a state prison for up to four years.

Abby had gotten into the room with his cat and her two-week-old kittens when someone accidentally left the door open.  She got along well with the mother cat, but was playing with one of the kittens too roughly and inadvertently killed it.  Evrard reacted out of anger and distress when he picked Abby up off of his grandmother’s lap and heaved her to the floor, but Kloch said that did not excuse him.

“You think the dog said in his little dog brain, ‘I’m going to commit murder, catricide?’  It was just doing what a dog does,” stressed Judge Kloch.  “Animals are animals, and we’re supposed to have higher brain power.  So why did you act like an animal?”

Jason Evrard

“I wasn’t thinking,” Evrard replied.

Kloch was not satisfied with this answer, and asked the defendant how he would be assured that the same might not happen to the man’s children.  He has a history of violence, and Evrard told the judge that he had taken an anger management course in jail.  Kloch made additional anger management courses conditional to his probation to safeguard against such behavior happening in the future.

2 thoughts on “Judge has Harsh Words for Man who Hurled Dog to the Floor”

  1. Sounds to me like the grandmother is suffering quite a lot by losing the comfort and companionship through no fault of her own. Her jerk grandson ought to be made to pay the medical expenses so she can have her little dog back. Why the hell isn’t he?

  2. Every single day of this scum’s probation he should be hoisted into the air about 12 feet up and let fly to a cement floor. Over and over and over. According to this story he has a “history of violence.” What this country needs is eye-for-an-eye punishment. It seems this judge is aware of the potential for further violence by this offender. In my opinion, only harsh, extreme like-for-like punishment works for these bioentities (not human, that is a degradation of the term “human”) who are a waste of planetary space and oxygen. I bet if these offenders knew beforehand that upon conviction they would suffer the same treatment they meted out on the helpless, they would stop before doing it.

    I cannot understand why this perp is not being forced to pay for the dog’s treatment. And there should be some sort of a victim fund for helping animals who are injured this way especially when the owner cannot afford care (especially elderly on fixed income, social security doesn’t cover the huge fees gouged by greedy veterinarians). I think every single convict in an animal abuse or neglect case should be forced to pay hundreds of dollars every year for the rest of their life into an animal victim fund!


Leave a Comment