Potty Training

Bark Potty Vs Fresh Patch: Which Potty Solution Is Right For Your Dog?

by Karen Parquet

Life With Dogs is reader-supported. We may earn a small commission through products purchased using links on this page.

If you’re a dog owner, chances are you’ve considered investing in an artificial grass potty solution for your pet. After all, potty training a puppy can be a messy business. But with so many options on the market, it’s hard to decide which one is right for you and your pup.

In this blog post, we’ll pit two popular options against each other: Fresh Patch and Bark Potty. Read on for a side-by-side comparison of these two products.

Bark Potty vs. Fresh Patch Comparison


Bark Potty

Fresh Patch



– Made of real bark

– Lightweight and portable

– Biodegradable

– Real grass

– Easy to maintain

– Built-in drainage system



– It can be pricey, depending on where you buy it

– Some dogs may not be attracted to the smell of bark

– It may not attract some dogs to grass

– Not as absorbent as some other materials

Product Overview: Bark Potty vs. Fresh Patch

The Case for Fresh Patch

Puppy Potty Training Fresh Patch

Fresh Patch is a grass mat designed for indoor potty solutions. Like Bark Potty, it’s easy to set up and comes with a training guide. However, one of the major advantages of Fresh Patch is that you can use it outdoors and indoors. This makes it a great option if you live in an apartment or don’t have access to a backyard.


Real grass gives your pup a realistic potty for dogs 

Easy to maintain

Reasonably priced compared to other options on the market

Built-in drainage system


It may not attract some dogs to grass, though you can always use a potty training spray to get them started.

Not as absorbent as some other materials, so you may need more than one if you have a large dog or if you’re gone for long periods of time

It needs to be replaced every few months (depending on how much your dog uses it).

The Case for Bark Potty

Bark Potty Disposable Dog Potty beside a dog

Bark Potty is a grass mat that’s designed for indoor use. It’s easy to set up and comes with everything you need to get started, including a training guide. Best of all, it’s made from natural materials that are safe for your dog to use.


Made of real bark, so it’s like going potty in the great outdoors.

It naturally absorbs urine and eliminates odor.

Lightweight and portable

All-natural materials



It can be pricey, depending on where you buy it.

Some dogs may not be attracted to the smell of bark.

It is not as easy to clean as artificial grass mats (hoses off easily).

Bark Potty vs. Fresh Patch: Which Is Better for Potty Training?

If you’re potty training a small dog, then Bark Potty is probably the better option. It’s less expensive than Fresh Patch, and it will last longer since you don’t have to replace the grass as often. Plus, it’s easy to clean – just spray it down with a hose when your dog is done.

However, if you’re potty training a larger dog and need an extra-large potty grass pad, then Fresh Patch is probably a better option. It’s more expensive, but you won’t have to replace the grass as often. Plus, it has a built-in drainage system, so you don’t have to worry about cleaning it as often.

So, which is better? It really depends on your individual situation. If you’re potty training a small dog on a budget, then Bark Potty is probably the way to go. But if you’re potty training a large dog and want something that will last longer, then Fresh Patch is the better option.

DIY Dog Porch Potty

DIY Potty

If you’re a DIY type of person, this option is for you. You can make a patio potty for your dog using some simple materials. All you need is a plastic storage container, some hardware cloth, and some grass seed.

Then, line the bottom of the container with a hardware cloth. Fill the container with potting soil and grass seed. Water the seed until it germinates, and you’re ready to go!

Designate a Corner of the Patio for the Potty Area

One way to keep your patio looking nice while still providing a space for your dog to potty is to designate a corner of the patio as the potty area and place the fresh potty patch there. This can be done by putting up a small fence or gate around the area or even just using a different type of flooring material, like gravel or artificial turf.

Create an Indoor/Outdoor Potty Area

Another option for house training your dog is to create an indoor/outdoor potty area. This can be done by putting a doggy door in an exterior door of your house and leading to an enclosed patio area.

This way, your dog can go in and out as they please, and they’ll always have access to their own personal potty area. Just be sure that the indoor portion of the potty area is easy to clean in case of any accidents and is well-fenced in.

Use Puppy Pads in the Potty Area

Cute dog near underpad with wet spot

If you’re really struggling with house training your pup, another option is to use puppy pads in their designated potty area on the patio. Puppy pads are absorbent pads that mimic grass, making them perfect for indoor or outdoor use.

You can find puppy pads at most pet stores, and they’re relatively inexpensive. Just be sure to change them out regularly so that the area stays clean.

Can Dogs Poop on Fresh Patch?

Fresh Patch is a real grass patch that is delivered fresh to your door. It’s perfect for dogs who need to potty, both numbers one and two, while they’re inside or for those who live in apartments and don’t have access to a yard. Fresh Patch is completely safe for dogs and is easy to clean up – simply remove the waste daily and replace the grass as needed.


Designating a specific potty area for your dog on your patio is a great way to make house training easier and keep your outdoor space looking nice. There are many different ways you can create a potty area, so choose the one that best suits your needs and preferences.

And remember, even if you use puppy pads, it’s still important to take your pup outside regularly so they can get used to going potty in different places.

Leave a Comment